Wembley Trial

News has arrived via Building Magazine of the result of the ongoing dispute between Multiplex and CBUK. Judge Jackson has found that Cleveland Bridge are not liable for the temporary roofing costs.

The case centres on the breakdown between the two contracted parties that ultimately resulted in Cleveland Bridge leaving site.

According to reports in QS Week, which is documenting the trial, the two parties are suing each other for damages and breach of contract. According to the presiding Judge Jackson, the crux of the case hinges on which company folded first.

In a statement released this morning on Multiplex's website

The case that was heard yesterday in London dealt with only one element of the damages claim;
There already exists a contractual cap on all damages claims of GBP6 million;
While the judgement resulted in a reduction in the total amount able to be claimed by Multiplex for damages, Multiplex’s overall claim for damages still exceeds the GBP6 million cap on the damages claims;
Multiplex is considering appealing the decision;
Multiplex continues to pursue substantial claims for abatement; and
This judgement does not alter the overall expected financial outcome of the Wembley project.

So it seems the case will continue. Whilst extra time may well be needed, nobody wants to see this one settled on penalties...